Jesus Christ SuperStar / Godspell
I was going to title this post Jesus Christ Superstar vs Godspell, but that wouldn't be fair. I love both musicals. I can sing every lyric from both. They both had an incredible influence on me growing up (and to this day) and to be honest, as a youth they taught me more than any Sunday school class. (Or maybe I just wasn't in the right space for church learning at the time.) Every single year I watch them both on Holy Week. (Usually Good Friday, but not always. I do however, always watch.) This being Holy Saturday seemed for me to be a good time to talk about them both. Remember, these are my thoughts and experiences...you don't have to agree (or disagree) with me. But be open and thoughtful.
- Jesus Christ Superstar came first for me. As I have said my mom had the
Broadway album (which did NOT include the whole show. WHY?), and I
listened to it a lot. I was torn if I wanted to sing the role of
Judas or Jesus. Judas gets the amazing title number, but Jesus gets
"Gethsemane." I wanted both. With that said, the
best number of the show is "King Herod's Song." Because
this was my introduction to the show, NO ONE will be able to touch Ben
Vereen when it comes to Judas and Paul Ainsley gives the definitive
performance of Herod. (Sorry Josh Mostel and Alice Cooper who were
"fine" in the role, but can't match him.)
- I was introduced to Godspell one year while
attending a week long camp at church. (Was it Bible camp? Was
it called something else? I can only remember that I attended 2 or 3
times over the years when I was a youth.) I can remember playing the
Broadway (off Broadway?) album over and over again in the church's main
hall. We actually went to see the show in NYC. I don't know
what year it was. It certainly WASN'T 1971 (when it was off
Broadway), but how could we have gotten tickets to see it when it was on
Broadway in 1976? I do vaguely remember driving in possibly in a VW
microbus. The theater must have been small because we were not in a
balcony. And when, just before the intermission, the cast sang
"You Are the Light of the World" and invited everyone up for
wine ("let's have some wine!") I didn't go. (Sigh.) (Side note: Did anyone reading this actually see the Canadian production with Andrea Martin, Gilda Radner, Eugene Levy and Martin Short? If so...SPILL it all! It must have been AMAZING)
- As a teen I was introduced to the film of Godspell,
which aired on Channel 9 on Good Friday. While Victor Garber is a
perfectly good Jesus, Stephen Nathan will always be the definitive Jesus
for me (since it's his voice I first heard). The rest of the cast is
mostly from the Broadway cast, so the voices were very familiar to
me. The "new" song "Beautiful City" is a
particular favorite of mine and the "All for the Best" sequence
takes my breath away. (Watch it for yourself if you haven't.
It's pretty amazing; especially the dance sequence on top of the
unfinished World Trade Center...which makes my heart ache when I watch
it.) In the days before VCRs/DVDs/streaming, being home when this
showed was a MUST for me.
- I "think" I was in college when I finally
heard the full version of Jesus Christ Superstar. (There was
more?) Finally seeing the movie as well. (Probably on
HBO.) I loved how the movie begins with the cast arriving in the
desert on a bus; they are clearly about to put on a show and how it blends
the modern with the ancient. But perhaps most powerful is the fact
that when the show is over, the actors all board the bus again, with the
exception of Jesus (Ted Neely). That hit me.
- Also when I was in college with a minor in theater, my
core group of friends were also fans of Godspell. I'm pretty
sure we rented the movie. We also performed the song "All for
the Best" at the winter faculty frolic. (The only time I can
remember participating in the annual show.)
- Just before I graduated from college, I saw Jesus
Christ Superstar at The Paper Mill Playhouse (on Good Friday no
less!). It was a good production. Jesus was a little weak, but Judas
was intense. I know that when Judas hanged himself it was so well
done that I think many were concerned that something had gone wrong and a
real hanging had happened! (Amazingly, in checking out the dates of this,
I see that Tony Award winning director/choreographer, Susan Stroman was
the choreographer for this production!)
- My final JCS "experience" was watching the
"live" production on NBC on Easter Sunday in 2018. ( Jesus
Christ Superstar Live in Concert) Visually this is the best
production I have ever seen. The sets, the costumes, the
lights...the incorporation of the musicians into the show. Sarah Barielles
as Mary Magdalene brings a new dimension to the character. She is
the nurturer, the peacemaker, the caregiver...Every emotion plays on her
face and makes you feel. Furthermore, the ensemble is responsible
for really bringing the show to life. (Shout out to Micaela
Diamond who is now a semi-regular on one of my favorite shows Elsbeth. I believe this was one of her first shows/credits and she totally nails it)
Their actions and interactions make the show; especially at the end when
individually and thoughtfully kneel. The visuals are amazing; especially
when Jesus on the cross, is slowly "flown" out at the end
through a wall that opens in a cross shape. I know I am not
describing it well enough...so you need to see it.
These two shows and the multiple
productions that I have been lucky enough to see are more than just a Holy
week/Easter tradition for me. Whenever I watch (or listen), I think
and reflect. Often I am moved to tears. (Well, I am a sap.) For
that I am grateful.

Comments
Post a Comment