SOMWaD: CCRAP Numbers

In 4th grade, which was the first CCRAP experience we had my son performed at Level 4 for Language Arts and Literacy.  His score was 3 points over the Level 4 cut off.  His math performance was at Level 3, which is obviously not as good as Level 4.  Supposedly that means he was approaching expectations.  (Who's expectations, I'm not exactly sure.)  His score was just a few points under what it would have taken to be Level 4.  (So he was just shy of achieving the "Met Expectations" level.)

In 5th grade, his second year of CCRAP he performed at Level 4 for Language Arts and Literacy.  This time his number was slightly higher.  Moving towards the middle of the "Met Expectations" range, but not close to the Exceeded Expectations.  In Math, he was still at the Level 3 but higher than the year before (but not by much.)

In reviewing the school, district and state averages for this past year, I see that in Language Arts and Literacy he is above the all the averages and in Math he is slightly below.  (He is much more above score wise, in Language Arts and Literacy when it comes to averages, than he is below in Math averages.)

What does any of this mean?  Absolutely nothing.  Spend one day with my kid in school and you could have predicted exactly what these "scores" supposedly told me.  He's slightly above average in one realm and slightly below average in another.  Academically, he is NOT incredibly gifted, nor is he in need of any special assistance.  CCCRAP tells me what I have known all along; he is an average kid.

Period.

Two years; two CCRAP tests.  He's average.  He's not extraordinary.  (At least according to their metric.)  He's a kid.  An average kid.

So what is the point of this test?  I could have told you what the results "said" years before.  Every teacher who has ever had him as a student could probably say the same thing.  And I'm betting that for as many CCRAP test as he may take in his life, he will continue to have the same results.

The test is pretty much pointless.  The "results" tell me what I already know.  And what the results don't say is that my kid is generally good, kind, caring and thoughtful.  These are all things that in addition to educational skills will shape the adult that he is to become.

So if this test isn't telling me (and anyone else) anything new about my kid.  If it isn't helping him in any way that I can see.  (If is supposed to, I don't see it, so please point it out.)  Isn't it time to cut the CCRAP and get back to basics?

Let teachers teach.  Have parents parent.  Most importantly, let kids be kids.  (Which I have come to realize sometimes means having a messy house while the kid goes outside to play with his friends instead of forcing him to clean up the mess that he invariably made.)

Kids doing kid things.  That's NOT CCRAP.  In fact, it just might be more educational than any test anyone could give.


As my son would say:  ya think?

Comments

  1. Mary AnnSeptember 23, 2016 at 4:25 PM

    Unfortunately, this is the federal government at work. Schools get extra funding for doing what the government tells them to do and the testing is part of it. We don't have the CCRAPs, we have "state tests" at the 3-8 grade levels and then Regent's exams at the high school level (of which they are required to pass a certain number in specific subjects in order to graduate). I am with you - let the teachers teach, that's why they paid all that money for college.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

We Have Taken America Back

Image
Back to a time when all men (and women) are not created equal.  Where women's healthcare is determined by men's laws and not by medical professionals. Where education tells only the "winning" side of the story and truth does not matter.  Where banning and burning books is a social event.  Where people who are "different" than those in power can be mocked, shunned and hurt with no real consequences. Where lies are acceptable and integrity is  just a word on a page We have moved into a time where rage is the rage.  Where hate is not just normal, but accepted and even cheered. Where leaders can ask to have their "enemies" killed and no one will bat an eye.  Where it's "funny" to see someone struggle.  Where felony is applauded. Where compassion is not shown and caring for others is looked down upon. We have taken America back to a time of pain and suffering for many.  Back to when the "haves" can have and the have nots don'
Read more

It's Not About Starbucks (or is it)?

Image
  About a block and a half from my home in a major intersection.  At the southeast corner (which is nearest to me), is an empty building.  Back in 1995 it was a Bank of NY (I remember this because they didn't shovel/de-ice their parking lot well and my husband fell and broke his ankle one Monday morning.  I recall this clearly because we were not yet married and it was the first day of a new job for me.  I had gotten on the bus to work and he was catching a later one; only he never got there.  Instead he ended up laying on the ground until an employee came to open up the bank.  Then he had them call an ambulance AND my mother who took control of the situation until I arrived home that night blissfully unaware of what had happened that day.)  It eventually became a Chase Bank; the second one in my small little town.  It eventually closed.  I'm not sure when but it's been empty for quite a long time.  (I do know that it was open in 2005 because the night before my son was bor
Read more

As Is

Image
  Today I want to discuss what I think it is a relatively simple concept, but may be difficult for some, even an attorney who might have once, over a decade ago won a  prestigious award  for young lawyers .  That term is "AS IS." As you may know, I volunteer in a thrift shop.  Everything we sell, from all the donations we receive, is "as is."  The items are not brand new.  They are not perfect.  That doesn't mean they aren't any good or worth something. They are sold "as is."  Buyers should go in knowing that. (After all you are shopping in a thrift shop!)  In some cases, particularly when we are offering higher end products, we will actually write on the price tag, "as is." Such is the case of two designer purses that I purchased from there this summer.  (I'm a purse-aholic!  Don't look in my closet.)  They were reasonably priced (especially when you consider the name brand), but each had an "as is" clearly marked o
Read more